1. Spanish Mission in Sydney Real Estate


    “Boomerang”, the 1926-28 Neville Hampson-designed Spanish Mission mansion in Elizabeth Bay that solidified the desirability of the style amongst Sydney’s elite. 

    In the first 20 years of the 20th Century, a renewed interest in California’s (and to a lesser extent Florida’s) Spanish Colonial past was sparked and the outcome was the widespread use of Spanish Colonial architectural idioms in domestic architecture. The Revival’s global introduction was through the expansive new building construction associated with Panama-California Exposition in San Diego in 1915 and quickly spread in warm weather climates across the English speaking world.

    Furthermore, “Hollywood stars of the inter-war years also gave the style a boost by favouring it for their luxurious, well-publicised homes—as did the press baron William Randolph Hearst when he commissioned Julia Morgan to design his grandiose San Simeon. While many such buildings completely lack the monastic virtues of simplicity and reticence, Spanish Mission is still an appropriate label. It was the aura of romance surrounding the old missions, rather than architectural specifics, which generated and maintained enthusiasm for the style.” (Apperly, Irving, Reynolds, 1989)

    But far more important than the influence of Hollywood was the architect and University of Sydney professor Leslie Wilkinson. According to Robin Boyd, “[n]o decorative fashion of the twentieth century owes as much to one man as did the Spanish Mission to Professor Leslie Wilkinson.” The Vaucluse home he designed for himself - Greenway - in 1922 showcased the style to Sydneysiders to wide acclaim. The Spanish Mission home was “planned carefully for Australia’s hot days.” Boyd continues, “[t]hey had wide, sheltered terraces screened by arcades…they ran to an open U-plan with a private central court.” However, in reality, such rambling Spanish Mission homes only appeared at the top-end with mansions such as the flamboyant (and Moorish-influenced) Boomerang and the understated Southern Highlands retreat “Shadowood”. Perhaps more common was the use of a diagonal entryway, a floor plan treatment often employed by F. Glynn Gillings to attract more light and recess an otherwise blunt street frontage.


    Recessed entryway in a Spanish Mission mansion shortly after construction. Unknown architect, but very F. Glynn Gilling in its aesthetic.

    Spanish Mission style had far more versatility than one of its contemporaries: the Californian Bungalow. While the Bungalow was popularized by the middle class and proliferated in the new suburbs; Spanish Mission first experienced popularity in the upper echelon of Sydney real estate. Almost immediately, the style could be seen “filling in” undeveloped portions of the established suburbs of Mosman and Bellevue Hill and in lavish apartment blocks lining the water at Bondi Beach, Manly, and Elizabeth Bay.

    Interestingly enough (and worthy of a post of its own) posterity has been far kinder to the Spanish Mission style in Melbourne than it has in Sydney. 


    Architect Leslie Wilkinson’s “Shadowood” in Burradoo in the Southern Highlands with its prominent courtyard.

    Here is the Radical Terrace’s rundown on the most significant Spanish Mission residences currently on the market in Sydney:


    1. 46 Vaucluse Road, a 1920s F. Glynn Gilling design, currently Sydney’s priciest Spanish Mission home on the market with an asking price above the $15m mark. Significant for its size, grandeur, by-the-book architectural detailings, and of course its price tag. Tragically, the interiors are not worthy of note. Not heritage listed.


    2. The waterfront property in Manly - Casa Mia - has been a Radical Terrace fixture this past year. It’s typical of Spanish Mission mansions that quickly attained popularity in Manly during its growth in the inter-war years. The property is not Heritage Listed and the home comes with plans for demolition and the construction of 4 modern apartments. Priced in the low-$4mils.


    3. This derelict Spanish Mission home near Sirius Cove in Mosman typifies the middle class adoption of the style. While almost identical in floor plan to the Bungalow, certain architectural treatments (stucco with a smeared pise effect, groups of triple arches, Cordova tiles, etc) distinguish the exterior aesthetic. 9 Sirius Cove is listed with $1.6m+ hopes as a development site and comes with approved plans for a multi-level modern dwelling.



    4. Fronting the Pacific Highway in Turramurra, 1A Warrangi Street is unique in that it typifies the Spanish Mission style in its floor plan as well. The home spans its corner lot, opening up to capture Western sun. The entrance foyer, accessed by a three-step rise, anchors the home. Also of note: the Barley-sugar columns, another fixture in the architectural style. The home is to auction with $900k+ hopes.


    5. An iconic - if not prototypical - interior of a double-storey Spanish Mission mansion in Bellevue Hill. The F. Glynn Gilling-designed home at 69 Kambala Road is currently on the market with mid-$6mil price expectations. While the front exterior of the home is a prime example of the style, the rear resembles more of the restrained inter-war neo-classical style Gilling is better known for.


    6. Now sandwiched between modern mid-rise apartment blocks, ‘Dungowan’ was once the largest building in Manly and anchored part of an architecturally cohesive Manly beachfront. Its construction in 1918 makes it one of the earliest examples of Spanish Mission in Sydney, however purists would argue that it only hints at Spanish Mission with its use of Juliet balconies, rendered stucco exterior, and tile roof. In reality, it’s considered to be of the Inter-War Free Classical Style. Apartment 17, a 2-bedroom apartment in the renovated block is for sale with $900k+ expectations.

  2. Blackett & Foster-Designed c1926 Bayfront Manse in Elwood Lists for $3.5m+

    Elwood is a unique pocket of the Melbourne bayfront; although situated between two of Melbourne’s earliest suburbs, St Kilda and Brighton, Elwood did not experience significant development until the time of Federation. Prior to the 1895 construction of the Elwood Canal, the suburb was the domain of uninhabitable swampland. The Canal was a mixed success and required hefty investment over the years, but the suburb of Elwood first saw the congregation of grandiose bayfront mansions followed by an inland development of California Bungalows, followed by inter-war and art deco homes and small-scale apartment blocks. ‘Ballatar’, one of the later bayfront mansions to be constructed in 1926, features the Spanish Revival architectural stylings popular at the time (and almost creepily similar to Carinya in Toorak and Towart Lodge, also in Toorak). Interestingly enough, Ballatar does not share an architect with either of those estates. Instead, it was designed by Blackett & Foster, noted Georgian Revivalists who departed from their traditional vernacular for a more seaside appropriate Mediterranean style. Today, the home has listed with $3.5m+ expectations.


    A c1902 sales subdivision map of Elwood displays the prominent early mansions that line “Beach Road”/”Esplanade”, and the early home allotments north of Ormond Road. The map is considerably out of scale in order to make the home sites appear closer to the water. The approximate location of Ballater is outlined in white.

    Ormond Esplanade was among the first stretches of Melbourne bayfront to give way to apartment blocks in the post-war years. Because of this, very few of the original single family homes exist on the road today making Ballater a slightly difficult home to comp. Thankfully, the home itself sold in a post-renovated state in late 2005 for $2.95m (and for $1.925m in 2001). The home has not been altered since its last sale. A smaller home on a 798sqm parcel at #67 sold earlier this year for $2.92m. A similar sized home on a 1,400sqm parcel at #31 sold in September 2010 for $4.2m, making Ballater’s $3.5m+ expectations seem almost suspiciously conservative. Mind you, Ballater’s 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom structure stands on a 1,045sqm corner block. Then again, give this home a Brighton address and the pricing would be far more aggressive, especially this season. There are handful of $8m+ Brighton properties currently floating on the market.

    The listing: ‘Ballater’, 39 Ormond Esplanade, Elwood

    Click below for more photos and a FLOOR PLAN!!

    Read More

  3. A Rare Del Rio Listing in Elizabeth Bay Wants $4m+

    The ‘Del Rio’, a stylish Spanish Mission apartment block, graces an enviable harbourfront Billyard Avenue location in Elizabeth Bay. The building was designed by J. Spencer Stansfield in 1928 and (surprisingly?) was considered to be the instigation for the popularisation of the Spanish Mission style in Sydney, despite the vernacular use in Leslie Wilkinson homes for several years prior. Interestingly enough, the architect Stansfield is better known for his master planning skills and his mastery of the Federation style, having been part of the firm that designed the garden suburb of Haberfield and over 1500 of its homes. Nonetheless, the collection of Spanish Mission-styled flats in Elizabeth Bay with their full-floor layouts are considered a hot commodity in Sydney seeing that sales seldom occur. 

    The $4m+ 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom (and 1 car spot!) comes with an aesthetically pleasing loggia, a nice harbour-view filled living room, and a shared harbourfront pool, garden, and jetty. The lack of images of a kitchen or floor plan slightly scares the Radical Terrace, but we love the building so much and doubt any interiors are hideous enough that they can’t be redeemed. Nick Harrington, a pro-active agent in the Potts Point and Elizabeth Bay space, has the trophy listing. The home most recently was listed for lease at $1,500 p/w

    The listing: 2/22-24 Billyard Avenue, Elizabeth Bay

  4. Troubled Frankston Manse - ‘Bruce Manor’/’Pinehill’ - Lists for $2m+

    A 1926 Spanish Revival mansion in Frankston built for former Australian Prime Minister Viscount Bruce has listed as a mortgagee sale with expectations in the low-$2mils. The heritage-listed home may or may not have been purchased in Oct 2002 for $895k (we can’t confirm) and was subsequently subdivided to include 10 villas. These 10 villas, and likely the manor home itself, were deemed uninhabitable in 2010 due to “safety concerns that may result in death”; not to understate or anything. Well, lo and behold, the main house whose exterior looks like a Calabasas tract home and sits on a one-acre lot in sub-prime, inland Frankston now needs to be sold. The home has 10-bedrooms (cult compound, anyone?), 5-bathrooms and bizarrely scant landscaping. One good thing to come out of its heritage listing is the immaculately well-kept wood panelled interiors. One thing that wasn’t maintained? The 400-acre grounds the estate initially possessed. 

    Click below for more images, a floor plan of the 10 bedrooms, and listing information.

    Read More

  5. (Historic?) Manly Mansion Up for Sale

    A prominent 1930-built Manly mansion - ‘Casa Mia’ - has listed with $4.2m hopes. The current owner, Queensland-based plastic surgeon Dr Mark McGovern, purchased the waterfront abode in June 2007 for $5.65m, a large amount for what became an apartment block after subdivision in the 1970s. McGovern proceeded to submit controversial plans to the Manly Council to demolish Casa Mia and develop a block of three flats with a construction value of $4.5m (putting McGovern in at over $10m, a hard sum to gain back based on apartment comps in the area). Local residents, of course, flipped out, claiming the home had significant architectural significance. McGovern retorted: 

    I would like to reiterate that Council decided NOT to proceed with heritage listing on the basis of its own independent advice that the house had NO heritage merit. Whilst built circa 1929, extensive renovations and extensions occurred during the 1950’s and again in the 70’s, resulting in little of the original fabric remaining, particularly since subdivision of the single house into first five and later four flats. Come on, guys! This is a rather ugly pink block of flats which you are eulogizing! If you looked harder at the subject matter, it would be appreciated! In particular, the “architectural and aesthetic mediocrity which will replace it” has very considerable merit!!!

    So many [sic]s, it’s not even worth tracking them. McGovern’s sentiments are surprising given he’s a plastic surgeon: doesn’t he notice that the exterior is virtually identical to its origins? And isn’t the edifice the most significant feature for NIMBYs and Councils alike?  

    A bit about Casa Mia’s history. It was designed and built in 1930 by Lewis Kaberry, a prominent architect of theaters and private homes in the “Hollywood” or “Spanish Mission” style fast gaining prominence in Sydney in the inter-war years. Kaberry designed at least one other home in the ‘Oyama estate’, the 1925 ‘Casa del Mar’. Most homes in this ritzy enclave of Manly housed the relocating country fortunes of several farming families, including Casa Mia’s original owners, the Edwards family.  Also to note according to a 2005 Heritage Assessment, “Casa Mia benefited from this infilling prior to the Great War that helped create the almost rectangular block approximately 47’ x 188’, or 822 square metres.  At the time of the Oyama subdivision, Manly Council  reserved an easement marked “Drainage Reserve and Access to Water”, ten feet wide,  between Oyama Avenue and the high water mark. This easement and water access-way is still accessible via new concrete steps from Oyama Avenue, to the east of Casa Mia.  However, portion of the easement has been encroached upon by the lawns of Casa Mia and a sea-wall constructed that blocks water access and obscures original stone steps down to the water.”

    That same 2005 heritage assessment led to Manly Council placing the building on the Heritage List, a ruling that was (suspiciously?) overturned in 2007, just prior to the home’s $5.65m sale to Dr Mark McGovern. Someone was doing some seriously lobbying in Manly a few years back!

    3 Oyama Avenue is listed with Vince Donovan of Donovan Prestige. And, The Radical’s take is that the home will indeed be more valuable as three “penthouse-style” apartments, but most of that value is under the assumption that the mansion’s unique architectural pedigree remains in place. 

  6. Marcus Martin-designed 1930s Mansion in South Yarra Lists for $7m+

    A large Spanish Revival home on South Yarra’s Marne Street listed today with a fittingly large expectations of $7m+. The architect behind the asymmetric edifice is Marcus Martin, the prolific society architect (the Mark Sutter of his day, if you will) of the inter-war years in Melbourne. Martin’s signature Spanish Revival style reflected the overall trend in Australian society to emulate the stylings of Hollywood design; Australians finally began to look to the climactically similar California for design inspiration instead of the outdated Victorian aesthetic that previously dominated the suburban landscape. Marcus Martin’s homes (and country homesteads) featured exceedingly “modern” interiors of the time.

    But back to 3 (or 7?) Marne Street. The single family home is now on a motley street dotted with homes and apartment blocks from every notable architectural period in the Australian domestic tradition. The 6 bedroom home sits on a large 1,110 sqm block with an indoor swimming pavilion. It needs a hefty renovation to match the price, but its architectural pedigree justifies the expense. Michael Gibson and Andrew Baines of Kay & Burton South Yarra have the listing.